As admired by Kevin Lane Dearinger for the Lexington Theatre Company.
It’s the music. The orchestra. The soaring sounds. Choral harmonies and swelling hearts.
It’s the lights. Twinkling with expectation. Bright and celebratory.
It’s the scenery. Evocative of another time. An earlier innocence.
It’s the costumes. Cozy wools, knit caps. Feathered blues, Technicolor greens. and swirling reds.
It’s the dancing. Romantic. Robust. Precise. Joyous.
It’s the actors. Warm. Endearing. Eager. Honest. Breathtakingly talented.
It’s the story. Nostalgia made of gingerbread, cinnamon, hot cider, and love, both old and new.
It’s Irving Berlin. Irresistibly tuneful.
It’s Irving Berlin’s White Christmas at The Lex.
The curtain goes up somewhere on the European front. It’s Christmas Eve, 1944. Young men fighting for decency in a darkened world. And entertained by three of their own. Bob, Phil, and Sheldrake. Big smiles, bell-kicks, and jingling bells. Their jokes were wheezy when vaudeville was in diapers, but somehow there is hope for humanity in the air. The leading man sings a familiar song. That song. The melody seems simple. The lyrics fall into place like loved ones at the dinner table. The heart lifts. The tears well up. “Home” feels so far away, but maybe next year, maybe, just maybe, we’ll all be together again. Home.
White Christmas may be new to you. It may be part of your childhood. It is certainly part of the holidays and part of American cultural history.
Irving Berlin, America’s most American composer, wrote a series of calendar songs for the 1942 film Holiday Inn, and added new songs and old songs to the 1954 classic White Christmas. The Broadway musical, with a holiday feast of Berlin songs, last played at The Lex three years ago, and it comes back as a beloved old friend.
One of the best leading men ever to bless the Opera House stage, Matthew Amira reprises the role of Bob Wallace. He has been working steadily since he was last in Lexington. In musical and dramatic roles, he has played unhappy guys, bad guys, and goofy guys, but for White Christmas Matt is again the best of “good guys,” with a heart-melting voice, fleet feet, solid acting chops, droll comic timing, and a sincerity that is honest to the bone. Matt is a classic baritone, but with the ringing high notes of a tenor. He brings his heavenly tones to the title song and others, including “Count Your Blessings,” “How Deep Is the Ocean?” and “Blue Skies.”
Historical note: Exactly one-hundred years ago, Irving Berlin wrote “Blue Skies” as a gift to his newborn daughter, Mary Ellin. Matt, our leading man, has recently become a very proud papa to a beautiful little girl! “Nothing but blue skies from now on.”
As tender but cautious Betty Haynes, Stacie Bono matches Matt’s vulnerability and wry charm. Her beautiful face glows with soulful warmth. When she sings, hard-hearts melt and soft-hearts rejoice. Her “sister” scenes with “Judy” have the wonderful spark of true sororal affection (“Uh, huh!”), and when she falls for “Bob,” we all feel both the sudden thrill and undertow of trepidation. When she sings “Love, You Didn’t Do Right by Me,” we ache with her. True torch singers carry all the lovelorn poets of history in their hearts.
Some ill-informed cranks persist in declaring that musical-theatre performers are “not really actors.” In fact, they are particularly skilled actors, not only creating characters, establishing relationships, and driving plot with dialogue, but, like highly-trained Shakespeareans, they also navigate rhythm and rhyme to find human truth. While staying on pitch, too. Observe and listen to Stacie’s magic.
Watch and listen to the singing actors hired by The Lexington Theatre Company.
Molly Rushing, returning to The Lex as the ebullient Judy Haynes, and Cory Lingner, this production’s playful Phil Davis, are a dream team. They are not just a cute couple—although they certainly are a cute couple. Molly has a charming sass, a dazzler of a smile, and an elegant Audrey Hepburn neck. Even when relaxed, Cory’s face seems set with a Cheshire-cat grin of mischief. Their individual talents, training, and skill are spectacular. Combined? In “The Best Things Happen While You’re Dancing,” they revive the elegant, ballroom romanticism of Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers. Their feet are glorious but notice the grace of their arms and the way they hold their shoulders. (It’s called port de bras, y’all!) Then Molly and Cory tear up the stage with “I Love a Piano,” the show-stopping, crowd-pleasing second-act opener. They start gently, seductively, with clear, easy taps. Two hoofers lifted into cosmic magic by a star-dusting of ballet. Then they take off for the cosmos, harmonizing with voices, feet, and hearts. With exchanged glances, peeks for reassurance, darting eyes of mutual admiration, they are true partners in their considerable art.
It all looks so easy. Look closer. Still looks easy. It isn’t. But it is bliss.
A Lexington favorite but new to The Lex, Jennifer Roth has been shining in rehearsals as Martha Watson, the wise-cracking, eavesdropping, iconic “concierge” of White Christmas. She comes with the pipes and the timing. Like a petite Marjorie Main out to out-strut Merman and Jolson, she can plant herself onstage with arms akimbo, sensible and just crusty enough to bark a bit while never quite eclipsing her sentimental heart. In a reminder that theatre is very much a living and vulnerable art, a pesky vocal infection prevented Jennifer from performing at Wednesday’s dress-rehearsal. Director Lyndy Franklin Smith, total pro that she is, slapped on the wig and returned to her first love—performing. The invited audience cheered their support, but the company is hoping that Jen will be back with them soon. She, too, is a trouper.
Gregory North’s craggy General Waverly anchors the light-hearted romances to a deeper American story, and Greg’s performance is as pitch-perfect as it was three years ago—with gravitas, dignity, and even more charm. Twice he addresses his troops, and twice he embodies everything that makes us proud patriots and proud human beings.
Alex Mansoori is Ralph Sheldrake, a fast-talking theatrical manager, wheeling-and-dealing his “million-dollar propositions”—and landing his laughs. With gleeful exuberance. To borrow a phrase from Ralph, Alex is “a peach!”
With a flashing grin and pert intelligence, young Betty Harden is Susie Waverly (“Susan, actually!”), who has her own show-business agenda (“You can call me Broadway Sue!”). She also has her own struttin’ song in act two.
Welcome back to Wesley Byers, who has revived both his New-England-train-conductor honk for one character and his stage-managerial mania for another. Welcome, too, are Karyn Czar and Tim X Davis, actors who always own the stage; they also have one of the most unexpected musical entrances in the show. Hint: it rhymes with “show.”
A word about The Lex Ensemble. They dance, they sing, and if you watch, they are fully committed to the story-telling. They act. Watch them in “Snow” as they create a colorful parade of individual characters. Watch them as they step out in clean-cut cameos, knowing just how to establish their characters—and get their laughs. Wonderful pros, every one of them! Of course, when necessary, they can “sell it to the back row,” but, as the great Jimmy Durante sang, they know it has to “come from the heart.”
The technical and design departments at The Lex flash their own Fred-and-Ginger style with sets by David L. Arsenault supervised by Kevin D. Nedberg, Esther Neel and Will Goodlett, costumes coordinated by Robin L. McGee, with assistance from Maura Kesterson and Hart Hallos, sound design by Marcus Ross, props by clever Esther Neel, the always-heart-stopping lighting design by Tanya Harper, and the crackerjack stage management trio: Tori Moss, Megan Kathleen Smith, and Kathryn Whilden.
Lyndy Franklin Smith has again directed White Christmas with an eye for detail and a gentle tug at the tender heart. Mary “Tip-Top-in-Taps” Giattino (assisted by Elizabeth McGuire) has set Randy Skinner’s classic choreography with fire and finesse, and Dr. Brock Terry leads another large and accomplished orchestra (twenty-three musicians playing over-thirty-six instruments) with his trademark elan, astounding clarity, taste, and exquisite musicianship.
The great American actor Edwin Booth once wrote, “An actor is a sculptor who carves in snow.” Sometimes that snow is really glorious.
NOTE WELL, MY FRIENDS: DO NOT LEAVE AS THE CURTAIN CALL SEEMS TO END. THERE IS MORE TO COME, AND YOU WON’T WANT TO MISS THE PERFECT INTRODUCTION TO THE HOLIDAY SEASON.
The Lexington Theatre Company’s production of Irving Berlin’s White Christmas plays the Lexington Opera House for six performances, November 19-22.
Kevin Lane Dearinger is a retired actor, singer, and teacher. His published works include At the Lexington Opera House: a Scrapbook 1887-2026, four theatre histories, six poetry books, six plays, and two memoirs, Bad Sex in Kentucky and On Stage with Bette Davis: Inside the Fabulous Flop of Miss Moffat. For many years, he sang out to the back row, acted from his eager heart, and danced, as one astute critic put it, “with athletic grace.” In his soul, he still does all three. He counts among his blessings the privilege of sitting in on rehearsals with The Lexington Theatre Company.